Assimilation vs. Difference in LGBT Children’s Books

whosyourdaddyHere is the tenth in my series of quotes from Who’s Your Daddy? And Other Writings on Queer Parenting. I’ll be running them for a couple of weeks courtesy of the book’s editor, Rachel Epstein. I’m choosing the quotes I feel are most intriguing and thought provoking; I don’t always agree with the sentiments, but I hope they will spur some discussion in the comments and encourage you to seek out the book for yourselves.

For more on how to get this Canadian-published volume (and you should!), see my original post about it.

Today’s quote is from Anika Stafford’s “Beyond Normalization: An Analysis of Heteronormativity in Children’s Picture Books”:

The normalizing trends within children’s picture books depicting characters in same-sex relationships often shortchange literary quality and the ability to effectively convey a political message. Analyzing the books from both a literary and political framework, I found the concept of difference is often used in a problematic way. While espousing a politic of valuing diversity, the message frequently asserted is, conversely, that those outside the heterosexual mainstream are “okay” because they are normal and just like everyone else. If difference is only celebrated because it matches the status quo, then it is assimilation rather than difference that is actually being celebrated.

Scroll to Top